Do Hiring Managers Lie in Job Interviews?

Let’s face it, the interview process isn’t always sunshine and rainbows. While companies and candidates alike strive to present their best selves, a surprising number of hiring managers may not be entirely forthcoming. According to a recent CNBC survey, nearly 40% of hiring managers admitted to stretching the truth during interviews.

This raises a crucial question: why do hiring managers lie, and how can you, as a candidate, successfully navigate through these potential headwaters?

Hiring managers’ reasons for misstating facts can vary. Some might:

🤥 Inflate the role’s responsibilities or growth potential to attract top talent.

🤥 Downplay challenges or company issues to avoid scaring away candidates.

🤥 Make false promises about compensation or benefits to secure their ideal candidate.

🤥 Withhold crucial information about the team culture or work environment.

While outright lies are concerning, it’s crucial to differentiate them from harmless “selling points.” Here are some warning signs to watch out for:

🤏🏻 Inconsistencies: If the information you receive from different sources (employees, online reviews, etc.) contradicts the hiring manager’s claims, be cautious.

🤏🏻 Vagueness: Evasiveness or overly generic answers, especially regarding crucial aspects like team dynamics or career progression, could be a red flag.

🤏🏻 Excessive positivity: Unrealistic portrayals of a perfect work environment, devoid of any challenges, might be too good to be true.

🤏🏻 Broken promises: If the interview experience significantly differs from what was initially described, it’s a cause for concern.

Remember, the interview is a two-way street. We aren’t even addressing candidate embellishments today, but in addition to being honest, here’s how you can empower yourself:

🤔 Ask pointed questions: Seek clarity on aspects that seem too good to be true or raise doubts.

🤔 Conduct your own research: Leverage online resources, employee reviews, and professional networks to gather independent insights.

🤔 Trust your gut instinct: If something feels off, don’t ignore it. It might be your intuition trying to protect you.

🤔 Maintain open communication: Express amy concerns tactfully and directly to the hiring manager to gauge their response. (Remember 7/38/55)

Transparent and honest communication are vital for building trust and fostering a positive relationship – any type of relationship. If you encounter deception during the interview process, it might be an indicator of the company culture you’re entering. Choose wisely, and don’t be afraid to walk away if something doesn’t feel right.

#careercoach #jobinterviews #companyculture #CPAcareers